I watch it almost every year. I don’t want to say every year because when I was drinking, who knows what the fuck I was watching.
Anyway, I’ve noticed that I’m beginning to see some of these familiar stories differently. Stories I’ve watched for decades are revealing something I hadn’t noticed before. Or maybe I’m just seeing them through a different lens. And this year, Charlie Brown got to me.
For those of you who haven’t watched It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, there’s a scene where Charlie Brown and his friends go trick-or-treating. Charlie Brown has made his own ghost costume out of a bedsheet. Unfortunately, he had a little trouble with the scissors and cut too many holes in it.
It’s ridiculous, and it’s funny.
I used to laugh at that costume. I still do. But now I see something else. I see a little boy who did his best to make a costume. It didn’t turn out quite the way he intended, but he put it on anyway. He showed up. He participated. He went trick-or-treating with his friends, just like every other kid.
And then something happens.
At each house, the children compare what they’ve received. One gets candy. Another gets gum. Someone gets a popcorn ball. And Charlie Brown?
They go to another house, and Charlie Brown gets another rock. And another. While the other children are collecting treats, Charlie Brown is collecting rocks.
Now, can we talk about this for a minute? Who the fuck gives a kid a rock on Halloween?
Seriously! What kind of adults are living in this neighborhood? What the fuck did Charlie Brown ever do to these people? Here’s this little boy in his ridiculous homemade ghost costume, going door to door with his friends, and somebody decides to put a rock in his trick-or-treat bag. Not once, but repeatedly!
What a bunch of assholes.
And just like that, I’ve created an entire story about people I’ve never met. I don’t know who gave Charlie Brown those rocks. I don’t know why they gave him rocks. I don’t know anything about these people, but I’ve already decided who they are. They’re cruel, unkind, terrible people, and Charlie Brown is their victim.
There’s a worksheet!
But before we get there, there’s something else about this scene that has stayed with me. Charlie Brown keeps going. He gets a rock and goes to the next house. Another rock, another house. He doesn’t take off his costume, throw his bag on the ground, or go home. He keeps participating.
Why?
Is he hopeful that the next house will be different? Does he want to stay with his friends? Is he simply enjoying Halloween? I don’t know, and that’s important because I can make up all kinds of stories about why Charlie Brown does what he does.
I can call him resilient, hopeful, persistent, trusting, or optimistic. I can also call him naïve, gullible, or foolish. The same little boy, the same behavior, but entirely different stories. What I actually know is that Charlie Brown gets a rock and keeps going. And I find something incredibly beautiful about that.
I’ve always had a soft spot for Charlie Brown. There’s something about him that makes my heart sink. Maybe it’s his desire to belong, his willingness to keep trying, or the way he seems to encounter disappointment around every corner. I see kindness in him. I see vulnerability. I see someone doing his best to navigate life, even when life doesn’t seem particularly kind to him.
And I identify with him. Deeply.
But here’s where things get interesting. When I look at Charlie Brown, I see a little boy who deserves better. He should have gotten candy. Those adults should have treated him better. He shouldn’t have been singled out. Life shouldn’t be so hard for him.
As I sit with those thoughts, I begin to recognize something. I’m not just watching Charlie Brown’s story. I’m watching my own thinking about Charlie Brown’s story.
It’s all about me.
Of course it is, because everything I’m experiencing while watching that cartoon is happening within me. The sadness, the compassion, the outrage, and the judgments are all mine.
And when I look a little closer, I begin to recognize qualities in Charlie Brown that I see in myself. I’ve been hopeful, trusting, and persistent. I’ve also been naïve and gullible. I’ve wanted to belong. I’ve wanted people to like me. I’ve wanted to be treated kindly, and I’ve experienced disappointment.
Haven’t we all?
This is something I’ve come to appreciate through the work of Debbie Ford, Gabor Maté, and Byron Katie. When I recognize qualities in another person, whether I admire them or resist them, I have an opportunity to look within myself. Where do those qualities live in me? Where have I demonstrated them? And what stories am I telling about them?
Sometimes the very qualities I admire in another person are the ones I struggle to recognize in myself. And sometimes the qualities I judge most harshly are the ones I don’t want to admit I possess. That’s where self-inquiry becomes so valuable.
But let’s get back to that rock.
Who Gave You a Rock?
Not an actual rock, although if someone did, I’d love to hear that story.
I’m talking about those moments in life when you expected one thing and received something entirely different. Maybe you worked hard and didn’t get the promotion. Maybe someone you loved rejected you, or you were the kid who wasn’t invited to the party. Maybe a parent couldn’t give you the love or attention you wanted. Maybe your marriage ended, your mental health suffered, or your life simply didn’t turn out the way you imagined it would.
You expected candy. You got a rock.
And what did you make that mean?
I’m not good enough.
People don’t care about me.
Life isn’t fair.
I don’t deserve to be treated this way.
Something must be wrong with me.
Notice how quickly we move from what happened to what we believe it means.
A relationship ended. That’s what happened.
I’m unlovable. That’s a story.
You didn’t get the promotion. That’s what happened.
My boss doesn’t appreciate me. That’s a story.
Someone didn’t invite you to a gathering. That’s what happened.
They don’t like me. That’s a story.
Sometimes we carry those stories for years, even decades. We remember who gave us the rock. We remember how it felt. We remember what we decided about ourselves and the people involved, and we keep telling the story. Not necessarily because we want to suffer, but because we believe the story is true.
I know I have.
This is where The Work of Byron Katie has helped me tremendously. It gives me an opportunity to look at those beliefs, question them, and discover what else might be true. Not to justify someone’s behavior, pretend that painful experiences weren’t painful, or convince myself that I should be grateful for every rock I’ve received. But to notice how my thinking about an experience may be contributing to my suffering long after the experience itself has ended.
Let’s return to Charlie Brown for a moment.
“He should have gotten candy.”
Is it true?
Well, of course! It’s Halloween. He’s a little boy going trick-or-treating. What kind of monster gives a child a rock?
See how quickly I can defend that belief?
But can I absolutely know that he should have gotten candy?
He didn’t. He got a rock. And no amount of arguing with that reality is going to change what happened.
Now, how do I react when I believe that Charlie Brown should have gotten candy? I get angry. I judge the adults. I feel sorry for Charlie Brown. I turn him into a victim. I become so caught up in what should have happened that I almost miss what’s happening right in front of me.
A little boy is continuing to participate in life.
And who would I be watching that scene without the belief that Charlie Brown should have gotten candy?
Maybe I’d still feel tenderness toward him. Maybe I’d laugh at his costume and appreciate his persistence. Maybe I’d simply watch the story unfold without needing it to be different.
I don’t know what I’d discover until I sit with the questions, and that’s the beauty of inquiry. I don’t have to know the answers before I begin.
An Invitation to Inquiry
Now I’d like to invite you to bring your own rocks to The Work.
Think about a time when someone disappointed you, rejected you, or treated you in a way you believe they shouldn’t have. Not Charlie Brown’s experience, but yours.
Bring to mind the person who gave you that metaphorical rock. What did they do? What should they have done differently? What did you want from them that you didn’t receive? And what did you decide their behavior meant about you?
Perhaps your belief is They should have treated me better. They shouldn’t have rejected me. They should have appreciated me. I deserved more than what I got.
Choose one specific situation and one belief that still carries some emotional weight. Then take it to an OTFE worksheet.
As you move through the questions and turnarounds, allow yourself to be curious. Notice what comes up, where you resist, and what happens when you begin to consider something beyond the story you’ve been telling.
You might discover sadness you haven’t fully acknowledged. You might find compassion for someone you’ve judged harshly. You might recognize ways you’ve treated yourself similarly. Or perhaps you’ll discover that something you’ve been carrying for years doesn’t feel quite as heavy as it once did.
There’s no particular outcome we’re trying to achieve. We’re simply becoming more aware of what we believe and how those beliefs influence our experience of life.
And that brings me back to Charlie Brown.
I still wonder why he keeps going. I still feel tenderness toward that little boy in his homemade ghost costume. And yes, there’s still a part of me that wants to find those adults and ask them what the fuck they were thinking.
But I’m beginning to appreciate something else.
Charlie Brown doesn’t have a perfect costume. He doesn’t get what he wants, and he doesn’t have the Halloween experience I think he should have. And still, he participates. He knocks on another door, holds out his bag, and keeps going.
Maybe that’s what I admire most about him. Not that he never experiences disappointment, but that disappointment doesn’t always stop him from participating in life.
And perhaps that’s something I can recognize in myself, too.
I’ve received my share of rocks, and I’ve also kept going. Sometimes with grace and compassion, sometimes kicking and screaming, and sometimes carrying stories about what happened long after the moment had passed.
But I’m still here. Still participating. Still learning.
And maybe, just maybe, I can begin to put down some of the rocks I’ve been carrying. Not because they didn’t happen, but because I no longer need to carry every story I’ve attached to them.
Who’s the Lucy in your life? Who promised to hold the football and pulled it away just as you were about to kick?
And what are you still believing about that person?
There’s a worksheet waiting for you!
Think about a rock you’ve been carrying. What happened, and what story have you been telling yourself about it? Are you using alcohol to escape the disappointment, rejection, or pain? Or have you stopped drinking but find yourself still carrying those same stories?
Bring one of those beliefs to an OTFE worksheet. Approach it with curiosity and compassion, and notice what begins to soften.
You don’t have to do this work alone.
If you’re struggling with your relationship with alcohol, or you’ve stopped drinking but find yourself caught in the same painful patterns of thinking, I’d love to help. Through one-on-one coaching, we can explore the beliefs that keep you stuck and discover new ways to move forward with greater kindness and understanding.


