Can I question the story I’m telling about someone else?

I tell a lot of stories about other people. Some are kind, some are compassionate, and some are downright ugly.

I have stories about my parents, my ex-husband, the bullies who made my school years miserable, organized religion, and people who I have judged without knowing their whole story.

And then there’s Donald Trump.

Oh, the stories I can tell about Donald Trump.

Giving someone the benefit of the doubt is something I’ve been practicing for years, but I still struggle with it. Particularly when I believe someone has caused tremendous suffering. Because somewhere in my thinking, giving someone the benefit of the doubt means letting them off the hook.

But it doesn’t.

I can acknowledge that someone has caused harm and still recognize they are human. I can hold someone accountable without believing I know everything about them. And I can disagree with someone without allowing my judgements toward them to consume me.

I’ve done a lot of inquiry around my relationship with my mother. For years, I carried stories about who she was, what she did, and how she should have treated me.

Through that work, I began to understand more about her life. She experienced tremendous suffering of her own, struggled with her mental health, and had very little support. Much of her life was spent trying to survive.

Understanding those circumstances didn’t make my childhood different. It didn’t excuse the things that happened.

But something changed in me.

I softened.

My thinking softened. My body softened. My anxiety softened.

And I began to see my mother as a human being whose story was much bigger than the part I had experienced.

I’ve spent years questioning the stories I tell about people who have hurt me, disappointed me, and, yes, people I’ve hated. And somewhere along the way, I’ve begun to recognize something that my anger sometimes makes difficult to see.

They’re human, too.

They have histories I don’t fully understand, struggles I know nothing about, and experiences that have shaped who they’ve become. Recognizing they’re human doesn’t erase the harm they’ve caused. It doesn’t require me to forgive them or agree with them. But it reminds me that there’s more to a person than the story I’ve created about them.

Now, extending that same understanding to someone like Donald Trump? That’s another story.

I’ve taken him into inquiry more than once. I’ve questioned my judgments, examined my own behavior, and discovered that some of the traits I condemn in him are traits I’ve demonstrated myself.

That doesn’t mean our actions or their consequences are equivalent. It means I’m human, too.

And here’s something I have to remind myself: I don’t know every part of Donald Trump.

Someone in this world loves him.

It’s not me.

But someone does.

There are parts of his life I know nothing about, just as there are parts of everyone’s life I know nothing about.

Maybe giving someone the benefit of the doubt begins with acknowledging that my understanding of another human being will always be incomplete.

I don’t have to like them. I don’t have to agree with them. And I certainly don’t have to excuse harmful behavior.

I can simply loosen my grip on the story I’m telling.

Because when I’m consumed by anger and judgment, I’m the one experiencing that suffering. The person I’m arguing with in my head doesn’t even know I’m having the conversation.

And what I keep discovering is that giving someone else the benefit of the doubt eventually brings me back to giving myself the benefit of the doubt.

I can acknowledge that I judge people. That I get angry. That I sometimes struggle to find compassion.

And I can extend a little grace to myself for that, too.

It’s all about me. Not because the world revolves around me, but because my relationship with my thinking is where I can begin to make a difference.

Giving someone the benefit of the doubt doesn’t let them off the hook. It lets me loosen my grip on the story I am telling about them.

And sometimes, that’s enough to begin softening.


THIS WEEK’S INVITATION:

Think of someone who has recently irritated, disappointed, or upset you. Start small. You don’t have to begin with the person who has caused you the greatest pain.

Notice the story you’re telling about them.

Maybe they’re selfish, inconsiderate, dishonest, or just plain wrong.

Now ask yourself:

What do I actually know about this person, and what am I assuming?

Is it possible there’s something about their life or circumstances I don’t understand?

Can I acknowledge their behavior without making it the whole story of who they are?

You don’t have to find an excuse for what happened or convince yourself to feel differently.

Just notice what happens when you allow a little room for what you don’t know.

Does anything soften?

And if it doesn’t, can you give yourself the benefit of the doubt about that, too?


You can condemn someone’s actions, hold them accountable, disagree with everything they stand for, and still recognize that they’re human.

Their humanity isn’t conditional on their behavior.

And neither is yours.

Donald Trump is a human being, too. He has a history, relationships, fears, hopes, disappointments, and experiences that have shaped the person he is today. Just like the rest of us.

I don’t know what it’s like to be Donald Trump. I don’t know what he’s experienced behind closed doors, what he’s struggled with, or what he’s carried throughout his life. And while I may have strong opinions about his behavior, those opinions don’t tell me everything about the human being.

Someone loves him. Someone cares about him. And he is just as human as the people I find easier to love.

Perhaps that’s where compassion begins. Not with agreement, approval, or forgiveness, but with the willingness to recognize our shared humanity, even when doing so is difficult.

We are all so much more than the stories we tell about ourselves and each other. When we’re willing to question those stories, even just a little, we create room for understanding, compassion, and perhaps a little more peace.

And if you’re like me and you find yourself struggling to extend that compassion to someone else, remember that you can always begin by extending it to yourself.

That’s where the practice begins. And that’s where we can always return.


The Giving Season Is Better When We Share It

If this reflection spoke to you, consider sharing it with someone you love. Not because they need to change or do anything differently, but because kindness, grace, and compassion are gifts worth passing along.

Sometimes the simplest gift we can give someone is a gentle reminder that they’re worthy of kindness, too.